South Africa’s highest court has reaffirmed Misuzulu kaZwelithini as the rightful heir to the AmaZulu throne, bringing a decisive legal chapter to a long-running royal dispute.
The Constitutional Court of South Africa (ConCourt) has refused an appeal bid lodged by Prince Simakade Zulu and others, effectively upholding the October 2025 judgment of the Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa (SCA). The SCA had previously affirmed the decision by President Cyril Ramaphosa to officially recognize King Misuzulu as monarch of the Zulu nation.
In declining to hear the appeal, the ConCourt signaled that it found no compelling constitutional grounds to revisit the SCA’s findings. Legal experts say the decision effectively closes the door on the matter, solidifying King Misuzulu’s status as the legitimate ruler of the AmaZulu.
The dispute over the throne has been marked by divisions within the royal family following the passing of King Goodwill Zwelithini in 2021. Competing claims and legal challenges led to years of court battles, drawing national attention and raising questions about customary succession and the role of the state in recognizing traditional leadership.
President Ramaphosa’s recognition of King Misuzulu in 2022 was itself challenged in court, with Prince Simakade arguing procedural and customary irregularities. However, the SCA ruled that the President’s decision was lawful and consistent with constitutional and traditional frameworks governing kingship recognition.
By refusing the appeal, the ConCourt has effectively endorsed that interpretation, reinforcing both the legal process and the authority of the Presidency in matters of formal recognition. Analysts suggest the ruling may help stabilize leadership within the AmaZulu kingdom and allow focus to shift from litigation to governance and cultural unity.
Supporters of King Misuzulu have welcomed the outcome, describing it as a victory for tradition and continuity. Meanwhile, observers note that reconciliation within the royal family remains an important step toward unity among the Zulu people.
The ruling also underscores the Constitutional Court’s role as the final arbiter in disputes that intersect customary law and constitutional principles.
With the legal battle now settled, attention turns to the future of the AmaZulu nation under King Misuzulu’s leadership, as he continues to navigate both traditional responsibilities and modern constitutional realities.
