A dramatic courtroom moment unfolded this week after Crime Intelligence head Lt-Gen Dumisani Khumalo testified that alleged underworld figure Vusimuzi Cat Matlala holds dual citizenship, directly contradicting earlier sworn statements by Matlala and igniting fresh controversy around his identity, influence and reach.
Khumalo’s testimony delivered under oath, has intensified scrutiny of Matlala, a name long whispered in connection with organised crime networks, political intrigue and shadowy business dealings. According to the senior intelligence official verified intelligence and classified records indicate that Matlala possesses citizenship in South Africa as well as a second, undisclosed foreign nationality a claim that runs counter to Matlala previous assertion in court that he holds only South African citizenship.
This testimony strikes at the heart of credibility legal analysts said noting that conflicting sworn statements could have serious implications not only for Matlala defence strategy but also for any ongoing or future proceedings in which his nationality and movements are relevant.
Khumalo told the court that Crime Intelligence had conducted extensive background tracing on Matlala over several years uncovering travel patterns, documentation trails and international links that allegedly confirm the existence of dual citizenship. While sensitive details were withheld for security reasons, the general maintained that the information was reliable, corroborated and lawfully obtained.
The revelation adds a new layer to Matlala’s already controversial public profile. Often described as a powerful fixer with deep connections in both the business world and the criminal underworld, Matlala has repeatedly denied wrongdoing and portrayed himself as a legitimate entrepreneur unfairly targeted by authorities. His legal team has previously challenged the credibility of intelligence sources, arguing that allegations against him are driven by political motives rather than evidence.
However Khumalo testimony has shifted the spotlight back onto Matlala’s own statements under oath. If the court finds that Matlala knowingly misrepresented his citizenship status, legal experts warn it could expose him to charges of perjury further weakening his position and complicating his defence.
Outside the courtroom the testimony has sparked wider debate about the influence of transnational criminal networks in South Africa. Analysts argue that dual citizenship while not illegal can be strategically exploited by organised crime figures to move assets evade law enforcement and leverage jurisdictional loopholes.
SAPS officials declined to comment in detail, citing the sensitivity of ongoing proceedings, but confirmed that Crime Intelligence continues to work closely with prosecuting authorities. Civil society groups have called for full transparency stressing that the case underscores the importance of accountability at the highest levels of both crime and governance.
As the legal battle continues Khumalo explosive testimony has ensured that the question of who Cat Matlala really is and where his true allegiances lie will remain firmly in the national spotlight.
