Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge has strongly denied claims that he forced conversations with Andiswa Mengo, a secretary at the Makhanda judges’ office. Mbenenge, who faces sexual harassment allegations, testified at a judicial tribunal in Sandton on Wednesday.
Under questioning by evidence leader Advocate Salome Scheepers, Mbenenge stated that Mengo approached him first, complaining about being insulted by a court manager. He claimed he chose not to intervene in his official capacity as judge president.
However, Mengo previously testified that she later saw Mbenenge hugging the same court manager she had reported. Scheepers challenged Mbenenge, asking why he refused to help Mengo if he was romantically interested in her.
“Even though I was drawn to her, I decided to step back,” Mbenenge responded.
Scheepers pointed out that Mengo had been emotionally distressed after the altercation but felt comforted when Mbenenge encouraged her and offered a hug. “Given her vulnerable state, why continue a flirtatious conversation?” Scheepers asked.
Mbenenge defended his actions, saying, “A hug can relieve stress. She even sent a dancing and hug emoji, suggesting she wanted one.”
Requests for Photos Questioned
Scheepers also confronted Mbenenge about allegedly asking Mengo for nude photos multiple times. Mengo testified that these requests made her feel exposed.
“Why did you ask her to remove her jacket in photos?” Scheepers pressed.
Mbenenge replied, “I wanted to appreciate her appearance. The jacket blocked my view.” He denied that Mengo felt violated, insisting the messages were consensual.
Dispute Over Evidence
Mbenenge argued that some of Scheepers’ evidence did not align with the facts, claiming Mengo had legal support when reporting the matter. Scheepers countered, “With respect, Judge President, you’re now arguing.”
Protest Disrupts Hearing
The proceedings were briefly interrupted when two protesters from the Kwanele Foundation entered the room holding a “Justice for Mengo” sign. Presiding retired Judge Bernard Ngoepe ordered them to leave, reminding attendees that disruptions would not be tolerated.
Scheepers further accused Mbenenge of deleting incriminating messages, which he denied. “That’s speculation,” he said. “Some messages were sexual and deleted, but you can’t prove Mengo didn’t delete any herself.”
The tribunal continues as Mbenenge faces scrutiny over the allegations.