Forensic investigator Paul O’Sullivan has sparked national debate after making strong allegations against senior South African police leaders, calling them “rogue” and accusing them of criminal behaviour. His remarks have drawn sharp criticism from many South Africans and added tension to ongoing investigations into alleged corruption within the South African Police Service (SAPS).
O’Sullivan recently claimed that KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi, national police commissioner Fannie Masemola and Crime Intelligence head Dumisani Khumalo were involved in wrongdoing serious enough to justify prison time. He made these claims while linked to a parliamentary investigation looking into corruption, interference and misconduct within law enforcement.
The investigator argued that there have been long-standing “rogue elements” in the police and said his investigations over the years have uncovered criminal conduct involving senior officials. He insisted his goal is to present evidence to Parliament and expose what he believes is corruption inside the policing system.
However, his comments have not been accepted by everyone. Many South Africans have criticised O’Sullivan, questioning his claims and motives. The reaction reflects how divided public opinion remains about him, with some seeing him as a whistle-blower while others view him as controversial or unreliable.
The dispute comes at a time when Parliament is investigating allegations that organised crime and political interference may have infiltrated parts of the justice and law enforcement system. The committee is expected to review witness testimony and make recommendations on how to strengthen policing and restore public trust.
The situation also highlights long-running tensions between O’Sullivan and certain police leaders. Previous legal disputes and defamation claims have further complicated relationships between him and senior SAPS officials.
As investigations continue, the controversy is likely to keep the spotlight on accountability within South Africa’s police structures and the wider criminal justice system.
