A dramatic confrontation erupted in Parliament after EFF leader Julius Malema clashed with SAPS Lieutenant General Puleng Dimpane over her written submission claiming the 2023 EFF National Shutdown cost the police a staggering R368 million. The heated exchange has now gone viral, with Malema demanding clarity and accusing SAPS of presenting figures that do not add up.
During the committee session, Malema repeatedly questioned Dimpane, asking: “Which one is that one? R368 million? Which shutdown is this one?” His disbelief set the tone for a tense back-and-forth that left the room on edge. Dimpane explained that SAPS had deployed significant resources during the March 2023 shutdown to maintain law and order and protect citizens, insisting the amount reflected operational expenses.
But Malema was not satisfied. He claimed the SAPS had inflated the cost to portray the EFF in a negative light and questioned why such a high amount was supposedly spent on a protest that he insists remained peaceful across most parts of the country. Malema argued that the numbers seemed exaggerated and inconsistent with previous reports, prompting him to accuse the police of trying to score political points.
Observers say the confrontation highlights a growing tension between SAPS leadership and the EFF regarding the policing of protests. The National Shutdown, which the EFF organized to address issues such as load shedding, the economy, and governance failures, was heavily policed. SAPS positioned officers nationwide, deployed specialized units, and maintained high visibility throughout the day.
Dimpane insisted the spending was justified, explaining that law enforcement must prepare for worst-case scenarios during large demonstrations. She said proactive deployment prevents unrest and protects people and property. She maintained that SAPS acted responsibly and within mandate.
Meanwhile, political analysts say the disagreement points to deeper questions around transparency in police budgeting. Critics have long argued that SAPS needs to be more open about how its resources are allocated. The R368 million figure may now be reviewed more closely as the debate grows.
The public reaction online has been explosive, with many South Africans debating whether SAPS overspent or whether such costs are normal for a national security operation. The video clip of Malema repeatedly asking “Which one is that one?” has already become a social-media meme, driving further attention.
The matter will likely be revisited by Parliament as members push for clearer, itemized expenditure reports. With public trust in state institutions remaining fragile, this confrontation has reignited calls for greater accountability in how taxpayer funds are used.