Governance specialist and commentator Themba Moya has warned that the troubling revelations emerging from the Madlanga Commission of Inquiry should not be viewed as isolated cases, but rather as symptoms of a much broader and deeply entrenched crisis within South Africa’s local government sector.
Speaking in response to recent testimony before retired Justice Mbuyiseli Madlanga, Moya said the commission had merely “scratched the surface” of longstanding problems in municipalities across the country.
“The issues uncovered at the Madlanga commission are not isolated incidents,” he stressed. “They mirror a widespread pattern of dysfunction, political interference, compromised oversight and weakened accountability in local government.”
The commission, which is probing criminality and interference within the justice and policing ecosystem, has heard startling allegations involving senior officials, police structures, and politically connected individuals. But Moya argues that the behaviours, networks and governance failures highlighted in the hearings reflect the very same systemic weaknesses that have plagued municipal administrations for years.
According to Moya, the commission is exposing a national culture in which political influence overrides institutional integrity, weakening state structures from local municipalities to law enforcement agencies.
“These patterns are replicated across provinces,” he said. “Municipalities are collapsing not only because of financial mismanagement, but because the governance culture has deteriorated to a point where unlawful influence becomes normalised.”
Moya pointed to a series of recent audit outcomes, municipal collapses and service delivery failures as evidence that the problems flagged in the commission are deeply rooted. He warned that unless decisive action is taken to rebuild the capacity and independence of local government structures, the country’s governance crisis will continue to deepen.
“What we’re seeing at the Madlanga commission is a reflection of a much bigger storm,” he added. “The erosion of ethical leadership didn’t start yesterday — it’s the result of years of neglect, cadre deployment, and allowing political battles to seep into the administration.”
He further emphasised that the commission’s findings should serve as a catalyst for urgent reform rather than a mere historical record of wrongdoing.
“South Africans must understand that the revelations are part of a pattern, not an anomaly. Unless the recommendations are implemented with real political commitment, the same problems will reappear in different forms.”
Civil society groups and governance experts have echoed Moya’s concerns, calling for tighter enforcement of municipal legislation, stronger protection for whistle-blowers and more robust screening of senior officials.
The Madlanga Commission continues its hearings this week, with more testimonies expected to shed further light on the extent of institutional interference across the state.
