A matter of considerable interest was recently discussed before a significant public inquiry. Within the context of the Madlanga Commission, a notable account was presented regarding certain operational practices observed within the police service.
Testimony was heard from Mr. Xolani Nciza, whose statements shed light on what was described as an unconventional approach to official titles and duties. During his appearance, Mr. Nciza conveyed observations concerning Brigadier Julius Mkhwanazi.
It was explained how Brigadier Mkhwanazi was understood to present himself in a manner that varied from what might typically be expected. On occasions, he was heard to identify himself as the Acting Police Commissioner, indicating a very senior interim role.
However, it was also noted that he would, at other times, simply refer to himself by his established rank as Brigadier Julius Mkhwanazi. This alternating use of titles, it was pointed out, created an unusual perception of his official capacity and status within the organization.
Xolani Nciza tells the #MadlangaCommission that Brigadier Julius Mkhwanazi referred to himself as the Acting Police Commissioner or Brigadier Julius Mkhwanazi, saying it was unusual as Mkhwanazi seemed to be performing both functions. pic.twitter.com/7TZwkM0iJj
— MDN NEWS (@MDNnewss) November 12, 2025
The particular aspect that was highlighted as being out of the ordinary was the apparent simultaneous performance of these two distinct functions. It was observed that Brigadier Mkhwanazi seemed to be carrying out the responsibilities associated with being a brigadier, while at the very same time, also undertaking duties that would typically fall under an acting police commissioner.
The unusual nature of this situation was emphasized during the proceedings, as the proper demarcation of authority is generally considered vital in public service. Such an arrangement, where a single individual appeared to hold and operate under two separate high-level roles concurrently, was considered noteworthy by those providing evidence.
The distinct roles of a brigadier and an acting police commissioner are generally understood to be separate positions, each demanding full attention and adherence to specific lines of authority and command. Therefore, the reported manner in which these roles appeared to be merged and exercised by Brigadier Mkhwanazi was deemed to be a point of particular interest and careful consideration during the commission’s hearings.