During a recent meeting of Parliament’s Ad-Hoc Committee, a tense exchange took place when MK Party Member Sibonelo Nomvalo questioned whether South Africa actually needs two Deputy Police Ministers. The discussion was sparked by Deputy Minister Cassel Mathale’s admission that, more than a year after he was appointed, he still does not have official delegated authority within the South African Police Service (SAPS).
Nomvalo’s question, “Do we need two Deputy Ministers in SAPS?” highlighted growing concerns among the public and critics about the efficiency of political appointments and the apparent overlap of roles within government departments. Many are worried that having multiple deputy ministers with unclear responsibilities could lead to confusion and wasted resources.
Mathale responded firmly, defending the current setup. He stated that having two deputy ministers is valuable and that both he and Deputy Minister Polly Boshielo contribute meaningfully to the department’s work. Mathale explained that even without formal delegation of authority, the department can still operate effectively. He emphasized that leadership is not just about paperwork but involves active engagement, strategic guidance, and vision.
He highlighted his own involvement in developing police strategies, strengthening oversight, and improving coordination within SAPS. Mathale’s position suggests that leadership within the police force extends beyond formal titles and delegation; it’s about influencing and guiding operations through practical action and oversight.
Nomvalo’s question has opened a broader debate about the role of political appointments and how public funds are used. Critics argue that without clear authority or defined duties, deputy ministers risk becoming symbolic figures—earning high salaries without delivering tangible results. This raises questions about the value of such positions and whether they truly contribute to effective governance and public safety.
The discussion underscores the need for clarity in government roles and responsibilities, especially within critical departments like the police. It also reflects ongoing concerns about accountability and the efficient use of public resources in South Africa’s political landscape