South Africa’s newly appointed Acting Police Minister, Professor Firoz Cachalia, has firmly opposed calls for a “shoot-to-kill” approach to crime, instead advocating for policing reforms based on accountability and professionalism.
In his first public address since taking office on July 13, 2025, Cachalia—a legal scholar and former Gauteng MEC—warned against extreme measures often demanded in high-crime areas. “We cannot fight lawlessness with more lawlessness,” he said, emphasizing restraint and judicial oversight in police operations.
His comments come amid growing public frustration over violent crime. While acknowledging the need for decisive action, Cachalia stressed that police must operate within constitutional limits. “A police force that ignores the rule of law ultimately harms the society it’s meant to protect,” he argued.
The statement follows recent allegations by KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner Lt-Gen Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi, who exposed alleged corruption and political interference within the SAPS. Cachalia condemned such misconduct but insisted on lawful investigations rather than extreme measures.
Opposition figures, including ActionSA’s Herman Mashaba, supported his call to protect whistleblowers like Mkhwanazi, calling it key to rebuilding public trust. Cachalia pledged stronger safeguards for those exposing wrongdoing.
Meanwhile, legal experts have questioned the constitutionality of his appointment, citing unclear provisions on acting ministers from outside Parliament. Cachalia acknowledged the debate, urging clarity from lawmakers and courts.
“Shoot to kill” isn’t the answer. Incoming police minister Firoz Cachalia says policing must be lawful and effective. pic.twitter.com/Zpd7nPi466
— Times LIVE (@TimesLIVE) July 18, 2025