Justice and Constitutional Development Minister Mmamoloko Kubayi has formally requested a detailed report from the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) following the controversial acquittal of Nigerian televangelist Timothy Omotoso. The high-profile case, which concluded on April 2, 2025, saw Omotoso and his co-accused, Lusanda Sulani and Zukiswa Sitho, cleared of all 32 charges—including rape, human trafficking, and racketeering—after an eight-year legal battle in the Gqeberha High Court.
The minister’s demand reflects growing concerns over the prosecution’s handling of the case, which has sparked renewed debate about South Africa’s justice system and its approach to gender-based violence. Kubayi expressed disappointment with the NPA’s performance, echoing frustrations from victims’ advocates and the public.
The acquittal came after Judge Irma Schoeman ruled that the state failed to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt, criticizing the prosecution’s weak cross-examination and lack of effort to uncover the truth. “Watching a young woman cry in court after the verdict was heartbreaking,” Kubayi said, highlighting the emotional impact of the outcome. She has invoked Section 33(a) of the NPA Act, requiring National Director of Public Prosecutions Shamila Batohi to submit a full report by Monday, April 7, explaining why the case collapsed.
The trial, which began with Omotoso’s arrest in April 2017, faced repeated delays, legal challenges, and claims of prosecutorial errors. The televangelist, leader of the Jesus Dominion International Church, was accused alongside Sulani and Sitho of exploiting vulnerable women under the pretext of religious activities. Despite the serious charges, the court found the state’s evidence lacking—a decision that has drawn backlash from activists who view it as a setback in addressing gender-based violence.
Kubayi’s call for accountability comes amid wider concerns about the justice system’s ability to protect victims and ensure accountability. “My fear is that this ruling may discourage others from coming forward,” she said, noting the potential chilling effect on survivors who risk public scrutiny to testify. The minister pledged to address the nation once the NPA’s report is received, emphasizing her commitment to rebuilding public trust.
As the NPA reviews the judgment for possible legal options, including an appeal, many South Africans are left questioning how such a high-stakes case fell apart—and whether justice was truly served.
